Skip to main content

Pink Triangles in Putin's Chechnya

On the 30th of June 2013, Russia implemented a law that prohibited the spread of information on homosexuality or portraying gay relationships as normal or positive, phrasing it as a law "for the Purpose of Protecting Children from Information Advocating for a Denial of Traditional Family Values". It says "Promotion of non-traditional sexual relations among minors, expressed in the dissemination of information aimed at the formation of non-traditional sexual facilities, attractiveness of non-traditional sexual relations, a distorted picture of the social equivalence of traditional and non-traditional sexual relations, or the imposition of information about non-traditional sexual relations, causing interest in relationships." This is what's known simply as the anti-gay law in more honest circles. From 2013 on, there were increasingly more gay people being arrested on charge of existing. Warning the rest of the world that this is not just a symbolic law to show themselves just how piously bigoted they are. More recently, a wave of arrests was prompted after gay rights group Gayrussia.ru applied for rights to celebrate a Pride parade (they were denied this, as is to be expected). On April the 2nd, reports on over a hundred men having been arrested on suspicion of being gay. What happens to their arrested citizens? The answer had turned out detestably more chilling than I've heard any respectable commentator predict. In March and April of this year, the Moscow-based newspaper Novaya Gazeta (New Gazette), which is held in high regard, reported on concentration camps having been built in Chechnya and used to detain gay people.

One such site in Argun
It's hard to pin down exactly where these camps are since they officially don't exist. Though two locations are found; in Argun and in Tsotsin-Yurt. At least three people have lost their lives already in the hands of Russian authorities in these internment sites. Without any judicial proceeding or legal process, mind you. Though these three deaths are enough of a violation of internationally agreed upon human rights standards to warrant diplomatic action, the actual number might run into the hundreds. It is difficult to know since Russia is actively pursuing journalists that cover this. If you want to know just how serious the Russian government really is in such pursuits, just ask the aforementioned Novaya Gazeta, which has seen six of its journalists killed due to previous investigations. The reason that the death toll might run into the hundreds (if not now, then perhaps tomorrow) is because that's a plausible number of detainees. There are at least about a hundred people being held captive at the moment (based on eyewitness reports of a few that have escaped or released due to 'lack of evidence'. There is no paperwork to go by. Not a single name is jotted down). All or most of these people are being severely maltreated by their government in the form of beatings, malnourishment, large groups being detained in one room for long stretches of time, being sat on bottles, sleep deprivation and electric shock treatment. That last act of barbarism in the hopes of 'curing' these men of their sexual orientation (note: electric shock treatment can be a genuinely helpful and humane way of combating certain mental issues. However, Novaya Gazeta has reported on torturous conditions and being gay is not a mental issue). The few that have gotten out can't be expected to return home, as death in the form of honor killing likely awaits them there. Once the government has outed you as gay, there is no place for you left in Chechnya. In fact, at least one guard is said to have released prisoners in exchange for their family's promise that they would kill the inmate. This is unverified, but depressingly unsurprising if true.

True to fashion, the Kremlin has denied everything. Just like they denied involvement in the death of opposition leader Boris Nemtsov, the death of former KFB agent Alexander Litvinenko, the death of anti-Putin activist Vladimir Kara-Murza and of course a string of dead journalists. No autonomic state is complete without dead journalists. Not only does Russia deny the existence of the campsites (which are very much real), Chechen President and serial human rights violator Ramzan Kadyrov has denied the existence of gay Russians altogether, stating "you can’t detain and harass someone who doesn’t exist in the republic." Which recalls similar statements made in the past. It might literally be a by-the-book response.

I understand that comparisons to nazi Germany automatically come across as hyperbolic and that the allusion to it in the title of this post might turn people off. In this case, however, it is an important comparison to make. The discussed camps are concentration camps by any definition. Concentration camps in which people are being tortured and killed, nowhere a judge to be found. Not making the comparison would be irresponsible. These are core human rights issues we're talking about. Let Moscow hear an international roar, instead of the current deafening silence. Why isn't there any substantial diplomatic pushback? The ugly truth about Saudi Arabia is that they can violate human rights without care because of their near monopoly on oil. Russia, on the other hand, does not have as strong a grip on global economics. Even if you'd sanction Russia severely enough as to cut it off entirely, the result would be cause for economic depression, not a collapse. I think most of us would deem it a matter of conscientious principle to exchange some economic prosperity for the closing of concentration camps. So which politician will be the first to grow a pair?

In the meantime, what can we do? Well, not much I'm afraid. Still, that's no excuse to do nothing at all. The are two major petitions. Neither will be of any use on its own, but maybe, by growth, they can raise awareness and so tip off the right people. Like I said, it's not much, but if you've got better ideas I'd like to hear them. These are the petitions: amnesty, change.

Main Source
Novaya Gazeta (who were able to break the story owing to the brave work of Elena Milashina)

Other Sources
Huffington Post / New York Times/ GayRussia.ru / Out Magazine / Human Rights Watch / uawire / The Standard UK /

Comments